Ask John: What’s John’s Opinion of Samurai 7?

Question:
What do you think about the new Samurai 7 anime? Also, what would you suggest a first time watcher to view first, Akira Kurosawa’s Seven Samurai or the anime?

Answer:
Regrettably, I’ve only watched the first 10 or so episodes of the 26 episode long Samurai 7 anime television series, so my ability to critique it is very limited. The show’s early episodes exhibit unusually high quality animation for a television series, and exceptional consideration addressed to background and setting, which is also unusual for contemporary anime. As the series progresses, I think it sees some decline in production quality and momentum in its story development. But it’s still an interesting and entertaining show. Its cast is appealing and interesting, and at its best, its action sequences are totally exhilerating.

The Samurai 7 anime is a loose adaptation of Akira Kurosawa’s classic 1954 film The Seven Samurai. Samurai 7 is not a direct remake, so directly comparing it to the original film fails to give the anime a fair opportunity to develop and exhibit its own unique characteristics. The Seven Samurai and Samurai 7 are individual works that stand on their own. Viewers who are familiar with both titles will be able to spot parallels and critique the way the Samurai 7 anime adopts particular elements from the earlier film. But it’s not necessary to be familiar with one of the titles in order to enjoy and appreciate the other. In fact, expecting too much similarity can restrict a viewer’s ability to recognize originality and creativity. I don’t think that it’s necessary at all for a viewer to diligently watch both The Seven Samurai and Samurai 7. Fans of traditional Japanese chambara films may disapprove of the idea of turning a masterpiece of world cinema into an animated science-fiction action/adventure. Conversely, I can imagine that many anime fans lack the mental fortitude to sit through a three hour long, black and white Japanese samurai drama.

The Seven Samurai is universally recognized as a classic motion picture. Based on my limited exposure to it, the Samurai 7 anime is an excellent series. A viewer only deprives him or herself by allowing obstinate principles to stand in the way of personal experience. I think the animators of Gonzo Studios respectfully attempted to create a unique, original adaptation of Kurosawa’s story with their own Samurai 7 anime. So curious fans should approach Samurai 7 with an open mind; prepared to appreciate and enjoy the show instead of predisposed to hate it just because it’s an adaptation of a revered source.